Monday, November 5, 2007

Malaise

I've noticed more and more a frustration in the art blogosphere. Maybe it's just the aftermath of big ol' events like Art & Soul, where you're flooded with the sight of other people's art. Maybe it's the profusion of art blogs (guilty, mostly) that cram even more art input into your brain than usual.

Maybe it's the rush to put together art in time for people to buy holiday gifts. Maybe it's just the damn holidays themselves.

But there's this continual, insistent thread that says, "Get your own damn art! Find your style and stop trying to bite mine already!"

Sometimes it's pretty literal. Sometimes it's a little more indirect. I was going to link to a couple of rants in particular, but I changed my mind. I don't want to make anyone feel like they're being watched through their studio windows.

Nonetheless, there's been quite the hullabaloo at the A&S Yahoo! group recently, for example. People have been discussing the use of photography during class, especially to take "notes." The kind of photos that could end up as the basis for someone else's "original" class.

Jaysus, you'd think posters would say to themselves, "hey, someone's already said pretty much what I've said. I'm going to keep silent." Oh no. Not really. Which leads to this: A couple of people seemed on the verge of lynching one particular artist because her artwork seemed too similar to that of Nina Bagley for it to be mere coincidence.

And it makes me a little nervous too, because I do have an artistic point of view... I do things a little differently from the next artist... but I can feel myself Looking For the Next Big Thing, too. There are wings on all sorts of pieces I've made. Shoot, just look at this. (But I had to use them! They're so pretty, and I'm just trying to stop hoarding my Good Stuff!) I'm just not at the point where you could blindfold yourself and still pick out my stuff from everyone else's. I know I have my thing, but it's not yet my THING.

It looks like we're all suffering a bit from Too Much Information, even the good kind. The studenty types are ravenous for more of anything from the instructory types -- more posts -- more online gallery pics -- more class samples -- more projects more more more. I think the professionals are feeling like they're being eaten alive. The scene is eating itself, and not in a good way.

And the same zines/magazines much of us read -- or are featured in, you-know-who-you-are -- feed the mania. I used to write for a teeny weeny trade magazine (totally different industry) and then for TV. These days, all sorts of media, from TV to magazines to online publications, spend much of their time repurposing stuff. It's not labeled that way, but that's what you're seeing. And it's possible, in this milieu, because so many people are creating so much that there's a niche for every last piece, it seems. And we devour it. So another Special Publication comes out. And another.

Don't get me wrong, I don't want to interfere with anyone's livelihood. But I wouldn't be surprised if we see a slowdown in some of the more informal artistic output, like blog posts (or maybe we'll see posts that are more about The Part of Life that Gets in the Way of Art).

Maybe, just for the sake of sanity, maybe we need to keep some stuff secret for a while.

UPDATE: The lovely and insightful new reader Kelly made some interesting comments on this phenomenon. Go see how clever she is.

8 comments:

Catherine said...

You are a very smart lady. I'm happy I know you.

P.S. there is something in your control panel that will allow "other" commenters of you turn it on.

BloggingQueen said...

Well, thank you! That's very sweet of you to say, and oh so accurate. ;o) I'll check out the "other" commenters thing.

kelly said...

Just started reading your blog, I've noticed the same anger. I hope too much 'sharing' doesn't cause an implosion.

BloggingQueen said...

Interesting thought, Kelly... I figure that there has to be some sort of shakedown or change on the horizon, though. What it means, though, I don't know. Maybe that means some magazines will fold because there are too many niches and not enough subscribing readers. I doubt it would mean lawsuits... there are a lot of "amateurs," as compared to those who make a living from their art, but I get the impression that the "professionals" aren't getting rich either.

What I really hope is that it doesn't become too much of a fad, you know? Like the scrapbooking products that flirt with creative abandon, but are really much too standardized to be truly risky. (No offense intended if you adore scrapbooking products -- I've bought so many things myself that I didn't know I needed until I walked into the store...)

kelly said...

One thing I've noticed is 'everyone' is taking the same classes taught by the same people and attending the same conferences. We also all look at similar sites on the internet. A great recipe for homogenized work?

Tally O said...

Good subject, Lisa. I struggle with this myself. They do say that copying is the best form of flattery. I think it's important for some people to emulate what they love before they can find their own path and voice.

kecia said...

hey! i am assuming you saw my post in response to the public flogging of the alleged "copy cater" of Nina.

i thought the poster was extremely harsh and quick to cause chaos.

people have been copying art for years. what do you think art students do - they copy from the Masters and learn from there. yes, eventually we all hope that our own style will develop, but for the most part - retreats like artnsoul are attended by the novice - someone who is dabbling and loves what is happening right now. when i take a class, i am attracted to what the teacher has done. i'm interested in learning it and playing with and doing with it what i will. will some of my stuff look like the teachers? of course, what do you expect it to look like? hehe. sure a lot of art is homogenized, we are all reading Somerset magazine, etc. it is encouraging us with their articles on how to do this, or do that. etc.

but i think this is inside the bubble of retreats - there is a world outside of artnsoul, artfest, etc. around where i live, people have no clue what altered arts are - so to them, what i am doing has a fresh look - it's different, interesting.

i also think that there is plenty of business to go around for artists. there are people who will only buy from Nina. great for them! but i don't know much of nina's work and i've found similar things (so i'm told) for less money, but that i love. am i bad for buying from them? i don't think so. i also don't think i can afford Nina's jewelry - but i can afford this other woman's stuff who is talented in her own right.

as far as keeping some secrets about your work, i truely believe though that sometimes what you think for yourself is an original idea or style has already been tried by someone else with the same idea! we are human after all and we do generally think alike!

am i making any sense here? lol.

Deryn Mentock said...

Here's a thought...people look for ways to tear others down. It makes them feel better about themselves and the drama keeps some folks going. Harsh criticism? Ignorant judgments? A public flogging? Let's all join in cause it's exciting. Besides, it's easy to be mean and not as much fun to be kind.